OMNOLOGOS.com v2.0

Welcome to the newest incarnation of Omnologos.com, featuring all posts previously available at

History (at NASA) shows what’s wrong with “Scientific Consensus”

What has been will be again,
what has been done will be done again;
there is nothing new under the sun. (NIV)

Quotes from NASA’s Earth Observatory pages about Alfred Wegener:

  • the international geological community’s reaction to Wegener’s theory was militantly hostile.
  • Wegener’s [...] cogent and comprehensive work [...] was impossible to ignore and ignited a firestorm of rage and rancor
  • most of the blistering attacks were aimed at Wegener himself, an outsider who seemed to be attacking the very foundations of geology.
  • Even though Wegener assembled many interlocking pieces of evidence to support his ideas, they were so radical that he was often ridiculed.
  • Because of this abuse,Wegener could not get a professorship at any German university.
  • In 1926 Wegener was invited to an international symposium in New York called to discuss his theory. Though he found some supporters, many speakers were sarcastic to the point of insult.
  • the merit of much [...] of his supporting evidence was not widely recognized at the time.
  • As a result, most geologists eventually dismissed his theory as a fairy tale or “mere geopoetry.”

Past performance suggests any date between 2018 and 2091 as the year CO2-based CAGW (or CO2-CAGW) went the way of the dodo.

A History Of Scientific Uncertainties (on their way to policymaking oblivion)

I know this story well about climate science. I am pretty sure it happens all the time in every scientific field that has social implications.

  1. The scientific paper details the uncertainties
  2. The IPCC chapter mentions the uncertainties
  3. The IPCC SPM (summary for policymakers) contains some indication of the uncertainties inside one item in the bibliography
  4. The Press Release doesn’t have space for the uncertainties apart from a side remark in the middle of the text
  5. The interviewed scientist is not asked about the uncertainties
  6. The journalistic article isn’t interested in the uncertainties
  7. The policymaker either doesn’t know the uncertainties exist, or pivots all his/her career about some of the uncertainties as reported to him/her third- or fourth-hand.

Broken telephones all around…

Omnologos – Twitter Updates for 2012-05-20

  • L'attentato a Brindisi non ha alcun senso. Anche la pista mafiosa, sarebbe qualcosa di assolutamente unico. #
  • Senseless to discuss if #Greece will suffer its Euro exit. If it doesn't somebody'll make sure the Greeks do. It's either them, or the Euro. #
  • Perché mai la mafia ucciderebbe quando può intimidire incendiando automobili a notte fonda? Dietro #Brindisi c'è la mano di uno stupido. #
  • Gli attentati del 1992 erano in posti come Firenze, non a #Brindisi dove tipi non del luogo si vedono solo fra la stazione e il porto. #
  • There's always a balance to be struck between what's right, what's just and what's fair @stevibaldi @kevinincornwall in reply to stevibaldi #
  • La mafia che uccide ragazzini non è mafia. Con le bombole del gas, poi? @a_rodighiero @vfeltri in reply to a_rodighiero #
  • Fra l'altro non è stata una strage di bambini "in generale", ma di bambine, come sa chiunque conosca quella scuola. #Brindisi #
  • Vorrei sapere chi ha il coraggio di mettere una bomba proprio lì. Un #Breivik 'de noantri? #Brindisi #
  • RT @b0yle: Looks like there'll be a couple dozen webcasts of the #annulareclipse – here's a viewing guide: http://t.co/HaQF9DEr #
  • E poi si meravigliano quando dico che vorrei partire fra 25 anni per Marte, e morire lì (o in viaggio). #Brindisi #
  • #Grillo commenta, poi mette link al suo nuovo libro. Lasciamo perdere. #Brindisi #
  • Con Grillo non solo prob ideologici con la sua "Scientology". Su ogni argom che conosco dice tante fesserie @guglielmopicchi @eugeniomarino2 #
  • La #Mafia vive di Stato assente e popolazione pacificata. Bomba a scuola sarebbe come un suicidio. #Brindisi #
  • Neanche nella spietatissima lotta per la droga in Messico nessun mafioso ha mai pensato di colpire una scuola. #Brindisi #
  • It's like #Chelsea is playing for #Bayern and viceversa. #toomuchfairplay #
  • Bayern have lost Ribéry but now they've got Torres #
  • Le "troppe coincidenze" a #Brindisi potrebbero essere un modo per sviare le indagini. #
  • Che noia i rigori. Blatter e Platini vadano a quel paese. #
  • Forget Hodgson! DI MATTEO FOREVER!!! #robertodimatteo #Chelsea #
  • RT @ivanscalfarotto: Domani Grillo dirà che a star fuori dall'Euro si vince pure la Champions League. #
  • Cara Angela i rigori tedeschi sono un fallimento!!! #merkel #
  • Fernando #Torres on being given the Cup: "So…who won?" #Chelsea #
  • Fired from his job tomorrow, #robertodimatteo will become Greek PM and turn the country richer than Brunei. #howtobeatthegermans #Chelsea #
  • Speriamo la #Grecia scelga Roberto Di Matteo come Primo Ministro visto che lui sa come vincere il rigore tedesco. #
  • Obama & friends continuano a dirci le solite platitudes. Ma che si incontrano a fare? >> @MarioPlatero in reply to MarioPlatero #

Omnologos – Twitter Updates for 2012-05-19

  • Ascolto il programma sul tablet avendo preso l'mp3 dal sito per l'orario 13-14. Adesso sono a Mercoledì 16. @MarioPlatero #
  • Ascoltare @Radio24_news in differita via mp3 ha effetti curiosi. (cont) #
  • Alcuni programmi (eg @alinomilan) invecchiano in fretta per ovvi motivi, altri (@MarioPlatero) vanno bene anche dopo una settimana. #Radio24 #
  • Certo chiedere che @Radio24_news renda disponibili le _trascrizioni_ dei programmi di @MarioPlatero @giucruciani @DAVIDPARENZO è troppo, uh? #
  • Sarebbe la prima radio per non-udenti @Radio24_news #
  • Somebody ought invent #OGM crops who specifically defend themselves from anti-OGM activists… @wilsonrobertj in reply to wilsonrobertj #
  • Ban Ki Moon asks youths to bother Governments. Another sign #agw has become a form of mass manipulation and control. http://t.co/vPSTUIUt #
  • #Olimpiadi 1898: l'importante è partecipare. Olimpiadi 1960: l'importante è vincere. Olimpiadi 2012: l'importante è avere lo sponsor. #
  • #Olympics 1898:participation is everything. Olympics 1960:winning is everything. Olympics 2012:getting a sponsor is everything. #London2012 #
  • Perché mai @DeBortoliF ha il @Corriereit online pieno di 'scatti rubati' e 'gonne che si alzano'? Che razza di lettori pensa di avere? #
  • Considerato il numero dei politici coinvolti, contro #Lusi verrà organizzata la prima class-action per diffamazione. #
  • Hitler pioniere dell'Ambientalismo. Su questo #Borghezio ha ragione (come una pendola rotta). Meditate, ambientalisti, meditate. #
  • MT @gretawire: a big THUD for investors? (ended where it started): Shares of #Facebook closed at $38.23 http://t.co/vAceItDy #
  • #Facebook is an empty box without real value. Am afraid today's IPO will be remembered as one the signs of the 2010s aka the Empty Decade. #
  • Coup d'état set in Britain for June 5, 2012 http://t.co/lbQ7taa1 – well, at least it will look like one! #

Omnologos – Twitter Updates for 2012-05-18

  • Surreal moment at @BBCr4today. David Shukman shows rare skeptical attitude to tidal power. Interviewee doesn't reply. Interview carries on. #
  • And @BBCr4today continues. Told tidal energy will be "part of the mix". What part? 0.001%? Without numbers it's just empty words. #
  • Solo chi riceve le lettere minacciose e ricattatorie di #Equitalia può capire la disperazione diffusa @gcaradonna @jacopogiliberto in reply to jacopogiliberto #
  • Per poche decine € REGOLARMENTE PAGATE messo + affissione al Comune. Follia totale: bastava chiedere ricevuta @gcaradonna @jacopogiliberto in reply to jacopogiliberto #
  • Se #Equitalia potesse impiccare lo farebbe PRIMA di chiedere prove che scagionino il contribuente @gcaradonna @jacopogiliberto in reply to jacopogiliberto #
  • Se lotta alla mafia come lotta #Equitalia all'evasione, Sicilia Calabria e Campania sarebbero deserti nucleari @gcaradonna @jacopogiliberto in reply to jacopogiliberto #
  • No. In principle "marriage" means "making somebody a husband" ("maritus") @AxeCo2Tax in reply to AxeCo2Tax #
  • Geoengineering project canceled because of patent row. Demonstration that #agw isn't about saving the planet. #
  • Nuovo blog climatico da Carlo Carraro – un po' tanto "istituzionale" però http://t.co/biApmmZH @VeronicaClima @LucaLombroso #clima #
  • Did you move to Italy… @aDissentient in reply to aDissentient #
  • Am not sure why would anybody in Greece right now hang on to euro-based accounts who could become drachmas at any time. #
  • Due ditte Americane pensano di comprare la Grecia, il cui nome sarà cambiato in "Biblioprosopos" o "Melon". #
  • Large American corporations competing to buy Greece, whose name will be changed in "Biblioprosopos" or "Melon". #